Angela Craig’s heartbreaking last words—“Why do I hurt?”—were shared in a Colorado courtroom this week, casting a devastating light on the final moments of the 43-year-old mother of six. Her husband, James Craig, a 47-year-old dentist, is on trial for her murder after allegedly poisoning her protein shakes with cyanide, arsenic, and tetrahydrozoline over several days in March 2023.
Despite Angela’s hospitalization, prosecutors say Craig continued slipping her toxins until she was declared brain dead on March 15. He has pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder.
Family Testifies to Craig’s Disturbing Behavior
Angela’s sister-in-law, Renee Pray, told the court that Craig insisted she deliver antibiotics to Angela and make sure she took them. Shortly after, Angela’s health rapidly declined. Pray testified that Craig later shared Angela’s last words—“Why do I hurt?”—which left such an emotional impact that she wrote them down to remember.
Angela’s brother, Mark Pray, also recalled being asked by Craig to deliver medicine. He returned to find Angela unconscious. At the hospital, Craig’s apparent lack of urgency raised red flags. He told Mark to take his car and return home, which Mark described as strange—almost like Craig wanted to be alone with his wife.
Affairs, Financial Stress, and Secret Schemes
The trial has painted a picture of a double life: Craig allegedly juggled multiple affairs, including one with a Texas orthodontist he met in February 2023. On the eighth day of testimony, Elizabeth Gore—the fourth woman linked to Craig—testified that she met him through a sugar-dating site in late 2022. During their brief relationship, which ended the same month Angela died, Craig sent her around $8,000 and took her on a trip to Montana that ended abruptly after a call from Angela.
Prosecutors argue Craig was desperate—drowning in financial problems and tangled in infidelity. In contrast, the defense is trying to frame Angela as emotionally unstable and suicidal, claiming Craig’s romantic liaisons were unrelated to her death.
Shocking Jailhouse Allegations
One of Craig’s former cellmates dropped a bombshell in court, testifying that Craig tried to orchestrate a fake video featuring his daughter pretending Angela had asked to be poisoned. The same inmate claimed Craig also sought help plotting to kill the lead detective in his case.
Marriage Marred by Betrayal and Heartbreak
Testimony revealed a history of betrayal—Angela had discovered one of Craig’s affairs as early as 2018 and another in late 2022. Despite planning to leave him, she chose marriage counseling, hoping to repair the damage. Her tragic death—just months later—now lies at the heart of a gripping murder trial.
James Craig remains in custody as the trial continues, but the emotional weight of Angela’s final plea—“Why do I hurt?”—lingers in the courtroom as a haunting echo of what prosecutors claim was a calculated and cold-blooded betrayal.
This article has been carefully fact-checked by our editorial team to ensure accuracy and eliminate any misleading information. We are committed to maintaining the highest standards of integrity in our content.
Katie is a senior who has been on staff for three years. Her favorite type of stories to write is reviews and features. Katie’s favorite ice cream flavor is strawberry.
Leave a Reply